The ROI model

When an order goes wrong, what does it cost?

A late parcel can mean a replacement today and a customer who doesn't return. Estimate those costs with your numbers; the defaults are starting points, not claims about your business. Read the method →

Your numbers stay in your browser. No email gate or lead capture.

Choose your calculation

Your operation

42%

What an order contributes after cost of goods and shipping.

2.0%
The promise gap over five years
Annual baseline marginThe Promise Gap
Cumulative estimated promise gap over five years The upper line adds the cumulative cost estimate to each year's baseline contribution margin for illustration. It is not projected annual profit. Exact annual values follow the chart. The vertical axis is cropped. €10.54M €6.14M €0 Today €350k 1 €824k 2 €1.38M 3 €2.01M 4 €2.68M 5

The upper line adds the cumulative gap to annual margin for illustration, not as annual profit. The vertical axis is cropped.

How this estimate works

Each year adds the cost of putting failures right and the margin missed from customers lost in earlier years. The gap starts at zero today; missed orders begin the year after a customer leaves.

The same acquisition behavior is assumed in both scenarios. Extra customers can leave naturally, but do not leave because of failures; their handling costs are excluded. Future money is not discounted.

Simple uses these illustrative assumptions:

  • Contribution margin: 42% (starts at 42%; adjust it above).
  • 5% of orders go wrong; putting each one right costs €35.
  • 15% of customers who experience a failure do not return.
  • Customers place 2.4 orders a year and have a 3-year average remaining lifetime. After each future year, one-third leave naturally.

See the full method and sources.

Exact figures by year:

  • Today: failure costs €0, missed margin €0, cumulative gap €0.
  • Year 1: failure costs €350 000, missed margin €0, cumulative gap €350 000.
  • Year 2: failure costs €357 000, missed margin €116 755, cumulative gap €823 755.
  • Year 3: failure costs €364 140, missed margin €196 926, cumulative gap €1 384 821.
  • Year 4: failure costs €371 423, missed margin €252 756, cumulative gap €2 009 000.
  • Year 5: failure costs €378 851, missed margin €292 405, cumulative gap €2 680 257.
10 000 failures × €35  +  1 448 customers lost × €242 forward margin
The method · The five-year promise gap

When an order goes wrong, the cost can outlast it.

A missed delivery can mean a replacement today and a customer who doesn't order again. The five-year projection counts the cost of fixing failures as they happen, then estimates the repeat-order margin lost in later years. It shows the gap if failure-driven churn disappeared—not a promise that Hantera can recover all of it.

The five-year projection · Simple calculator
// Start today; the baseline includes the merchant's observed net growth.
baseline orders[year] = orders × (1 + customer growth) ^ (year − 1)
baseline customers    = baseline orders ÷ repeat orders
failure churn         = (1 − (1 − failure rate) ^ repeat orders) × churn rate
annual customer margin = repeat orders × AOV × margin %

// Lost customers miss future orders from the following year.
natural survival      = years ≥ 1 ? 1 − 1 ÷ years : 0
first-year share      = min(1, years)
extra customers[today] = 0
extra customers[next]  = extra customers × natural survival
                      + baseline customers × failure churn × first-year share
missed margin[year]   = extra customers × annual customer margin
failure costs[year]   = baseline orders × failure rate × cost to fix
cumulative gap        = sum of failure costs + missed margin through that year

// The lines compare annual baseline margin with the accumulated gap.
baseline margin       = baseline orders × AOV × margin %
upper line            = baseline margin + cumulative gap
/ 01

Year by year, not lifetime upfront.

Customers lost in one year start contributing missed orders in the next. With a three-year average remaining lifetime, the model assumes one-third of the extra customers naturally leave after each future year. Shorter-than-one-year lifetimes prorate the first year. The original one-year lifetime estimate is shown separately and is not added to the projection.

/ 02

A comparison, not a forecast.

Net growth continues at the rate entered, and the same acquisition behavior, ordering frequency, failure rate and margin apply across scenarios. The ideal retains customers who would have left after a failure; they can still leave naturally. Their hypothetical handling costs are not counted. No future money is discounted. The upper line combines an annual baseline with a cumulative gap for illustration—it is not annual profit.

Simple uses your contribution margin and starting assumptions for failure rate, churn, ordering and lifetime. Its current growth input is 2.0% per year. Currency defaults use rounded ECB reference rates from 9 November 2026 (€1 ≈ $1.12, £0.83 or 11 kr), not live rates or local-market benchmarks. Advanced lets you change assumptions for the original one-year ROI estimates below; it does not display the five-year projection.

Stated intent, discounted

Why we halve the churn figure.

The share of customers who leave after a bad experience is the single most powerful number in this model, and the only one you cannot get from your own books. So it is worth being explicit about what the published figure measures — and what it does not.

What PwC asked1“At what point would you stop interacting with a company that you love shopping at or using?”
32%
What this model usesLess than half of it, because intent is not behaviour
15%

That question asks what someone expects to do, in the abstract, with no basket in front of them and no inconvenience attached. It is a good measure of how strongly people feel. It is not a measure of what they were observed doing, and people abandon brands far less often than they say they will — particularly when leaving means finding a new supplier who has their sizes, their address and their payment details.

There is no published figure for the behaviour, so we do not pretend to one. We halve the intent figure, say plainly that the halving is a judgement rather than a finding, and leave the field where you can overwrite it. If you have measured your own post-incident retention, that number beats ours outright.

The sources

Quoted, linked, and dated.

Same rule as our integration benchmark: no paraphrasing a number we depend on. Where a figure is ours rather than published, we say so instead of borrowing someone else's authority for it.

Source 1 · PwC · 2018

The share who walk after one bad experience

“One in three consumers (32%) say they will walk away from a brand they love after just one bad experience. This figure is even higher in Latin America, at 49%.”

PwC, Experience is everything: Here’s how to get it right, Consumer Intelligence Series, 2018. Fieldwork: PwC Future of Customer Experience Survey 2017/18 — a representative sample of 15 000 people across 12 countries, surveyed online and in-field, 4 000 of them in the US. Accessed 16 Aug 2026.

pwc.com — Experience is everything (PDF)
Source 2 · Harvard Business Review · 29 Oct 2014

The cost of replacing a customer

“Depending on which study you believe, and what industry you're in, acquiring a new customer is anywhere from five to 25 times more expensive than retaining an existing one.”
“…research done by Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company … shows increasing customer retention rates by 5% increases profits by 25% to 95%.”

Amy Gallo, The Value of Keeping the Right Customers. Context for the Full model only — never a multiplier inside the arithmetic. Accessed 16 Aug 2026.

hbr.org/2014/10/the-value-of-keeping-the-right-customers
Source 3 · Our own published benchmark · July 2026

Estimating integration effort

Our integration benchmark explains how we derive an hours range and where that estimate is weak. A project's implementation cost depends on its scope and quote; the calculator does not supply a default price.

The ERP integration benchmark →
Source 4 · Polar Analytics · updated weekly

What acquiring a customer actually costs

There is no audited, cross-industry study of acquisition cost. What exists is platform data, and this is the largest set we found that publishes its method: medians across 4 000+ Shopify brands, tracked since December 2022, stated as medians rather than averages “to avoid skew from outliers”.

Retail $22.74 · Sports & Outdoor $27.66 · Apparel & Accessories $34.03 · Consumer Electronics $43.38 · Beauty & Personal Care $44.29 · Food & Beverage $49.39

Ecommerce Benchmarks: How Do You Stack Up? Accessed 16 Aug 2026

polaranalytics.com/ecommerce-benchmarks
Where this is weak

Why to treat this as a direction, not a forecast.

A model that only lists its strengths isn't a model, it's a brochure. These are the parts we'd attack if a competitor published them.

Growth doesn't reveal acquisition

Net customer growth combines gains and losses; it does not tell us how many customers were acquired or whether those flows fit the assumed lifetime and failure rate. The five-year illustration extrapolates your baseline and assumes the same acquisition behavior in both scenarios.

Three numbers are ours, and they are the whole claim

How many failures we prevent, how many customers we keep through recovery, and what share of status enquiries a proactive update makes unnecessary. These are our estimates of our own effect, with no controlled study behind them yet. In Advanced they can be set to zero; if platform costs remain, the ROI becomes negative. The five-year gap itself does not depend on those effectiveness assumptions.

Stated intent is not behaviour

Every published churn-after-a-bad-experience figure is a survey answer, including ours: PwC asked people at what point they would stop, and 32% said one bad experience was enough. People say they'll leave far more often than they actually leave, especially when leaving means finding a supplier who has their size, their address and their card on file. Halving it is our judgement, not a finding — and it is the one number here you cannot check against your own books.

Different horizons, no ramp

The original Advanced ROI credits future lifetime margin immediately; its payback is not cash-flow break-even. The five-year gap counts missed orders as they would occur and assumes a constant growth rate, fixed behavior and natural decay. Neither models rollout ramp-up or discounts future money.

Orders per customer is doing two jobs

Churn belongs to people, not orders: someone who hits two bad experiences in a year still only leaves once. The model estimates the customers behind your order volume using the assumed future orders of a retained customer. That may differ from ordering across your whole customer base, especially if you have many one-time buyers. Simple uses the default; in Advanced you can change it.

Nothing here counts churn caused by silence alone

A customer whose order arrived on time, but who spent four days in the dark and had to chase you twice, is not a “failure” in this model — so if they quietly leave, we don't count it. We think that pool is real, and we have nothing to size it with, so it is absent rather than estimated. That is the one omission on this page that works against us.

The cost side is the easy half

The fee, rate and implementation can be checked against a quote. Even the Conservative result depends on how much failure and enquiry handling can actually be prevented and whether that effort becomes a cash saving.